In a comment to the post in which I proclaimed the Shimmer Pirate Issue open to submissions, Danny Adams wrote:
This is a hypothetical question for me, but others might be wondering:
If you turned down a pirate story for F&SF, is it still all hands hoay for Shimmer?
That’s a good question, and here’s the answer: If I turned down a pirate story submitted to F&SF, I’d say don’t bother submitting it to Shimmer*. If Gordon, on the other hand, rejected your pirate story, by all means do send it to me. After all, if Gordon rejected it, there’s a good chance** I saw it first and passed it up to him, and so theoretically that means I would have liked it.
If anyone else has any other questions, please feel free to use this as an open thread to fire away.
——————————————————————
*Unless, of course, it’s been so drastically revised and improved that you feel it’s substantially changed as a story.
**I say a “good chance” because there are, of course, submissions Gordon looks at automatically (i.e., they don’t pass through the slush), so of course any stories like that are welcome too.
Read More